Thanksgiving at Sweet Melissa

Give thanks & eat dessert

Hand-made desserts for your Thanksgiving table: cheesecakes, family-style dessert trays, take-and-bake treats and our biggest cookie lineup of the fall. Baked fresh in Middletown, DE.

🍂 In the case Nov 24th & 25th
Vintage-style caramel cake with buttercream shells, orange ruffle swags and orange gingham ribbon bows
A sweet change this year

No pies this Thanksgiving, something even sweeter

We never cut corners. Our pies have always been made by hand, with quality ingredients, and ingredient costs where they are would mean charging more than we think any pie should cost.

So instead of raising prices or lowering our standards, we’re pouring all that love into a bigger-than-ever lineup of Thanksgiving desserts, made by hand and priced like a small family bakery should.

For your Thanksgiving table

The Thanksgiving Lineup

Stocked in the case November 24th and 25th. Come early, because when they’re gone, they’re gone!

Assorted mini cheesecakes

Cheesecakes Galore

Mini cheesecakes in Turtle, Classic Cherry, Pumpkin, Biscoff and Oreo, plus more cheesecakes than we bake all year.

Lots of mini desserts too, like chocolate peanut butter and triple chocolate.

Family-Style Dessert Trays

Banana Pudding$32
Rich and creamy, a house favorite!
Bread Pudding with Anglaise$32
Apple Cobbler$30

Each tray serves 10 and comes with reheating instructions.

Take and bake cookie dough

Take & Bake

Wake up Thanksgiving morning to a bakery-fresh smell, without the work.

Take & Bake available Wednesday, 11/25 ONLY.

Cinnamon Rolls, 4-pack with icing$25
Take ‘n Bake cookie doughready to bake
Chocolate Chip · Oatmeal Raisin

Brownie Combo Boxes

Combo boxes of rich, fudgy brownies with toppings like cookie dough & cookie pieces, caramel & nuts, Nutella, and cookies & cream.

Dessert Bars

Pecan Pie Bars
Even better than pie! Handheld slices of heaven: a rich shortbread crust with pecan pie filling on top.
Pumpkin Crumb Bars
Spiced pumpkin on shortbread with streusel. Happy at room temp all afternoon.

Thanksgiving Cookies

Maple-glazed ricotta cookies, butter pecan tea cakes, spiced gingerbread turkeys, chewy cranberry-coconut macaroons with white chocolate, and classic chocolate chip.

Combo Cookie Boxes (2 dozen): prepped boxes will be ready to grab Tuesday & Wednesday of Thanksgiving week.

Easy Entertaining

Mini cupcake trays (24 pcs.), assorted icings$28
DIY cookie kitsin the case
Chocolate-filled cannoliin the case

Available Tuesday & Wednesday of Thanksgiving week only. Plus cake loaves in rotating flavors.

Cookie Cakes

A giant, chewy chocolate chip cookie cake with piped buttercream turkeys and Happy Thanksgiving lettering, a centerpiece dessert everyone fights over.

Cookie Cake with Thanksgiving décor$35

Signature Sugar Cookies

Our signature decorative sugar cookies, dressed for the holiday: turkeys, pumpkins and other fall designs, available for purchase all Thanksgiving week.

Pumpkin roll

Fall favorite

Pumpkin Rolls

Spiced pumpkin cake rolled around a sweet cream cheese filling, the Thanksgiving classic, no pie required.

$16.95 · serves 6
Bake at home

Take ‘n Bake Cookies

Our scratch-made cookie dough, prepped in the bakery and ready for your oven: warm, fresh-baked cookies whenever you want them Thanksgiving week.

Available November 24th and 25th.

Chocolate Chip · Oatmeal Raisin

Take and bake cookie dough, chocolate chip and oatmeal raisin

Hand-piped for the holiday

Vintage Thanksgiving Cakes

Ruffles, shells and swags in harvest colors, finished with velvet and gingham bows.

Vintage-style cake with a lattice pie top, caramel and cream buttercream shells, raspberry ruffles and a burgundy velvet bow
Vintage-style caramel cake with buttercream shells, orange ruffle swags and orange gingham ribbon bows
Plus all your favorites, Thanksgiving style

Cupcakes · Cake Pops · Cakes & More

Decorated for the season, with turkeys, fall leaves and harvest colors. In the case all Thanksgiving week, first come, first served.

Buttercream cupcakesCake pops
A friendly heads-up: we’re not taking custom orders Thanksgiving week, sorry! Everything is first come, first served in the case. Come early for the best pick.

Closed Thanksgiving Day and Black Friday.