Our best seller

Cake Pop Menu

Big, moist and dipped in the finest chocolate.
Pick some up in the case any day, or order a custom batch for your next celebration!

Pink cake pops with sprinkles on a plate

What are cake pops?

Our cake pops are our biggest selling item, and we make our balls BIG! They’re made with freshly baked cake and real buttercream, rolled like rich truffles, then dipped in the finest chocolate. They are not balls of dry cake, so they stay super moist and delicious.

We carry 15–20 flavors every day in assorted dessert style flavors that change with the seasons.

In the case daily

1 cake pop$3.25
6 cake pops$18
12 cake pops$35
Gluten free pops$3.50 each

No order needed.

Storing your pops

Keep cake pops refrigerated for up to 1 week, or freeze them for up to 6 months!

Pre-order

Custom & Classic Cake Pops

White chocolate cake pops with caramel drizzle on honey dipper sticks

Custom Color & Designed Pops

Choose your flavors, colors and decorations. Great for weddings, showers, birthdays or just because!

PriceFrom $42 per dozen
Lead time1 week
Minimum1 dozen
Per dozen1 flavor & 1 design

CLICK HERE for info on custom pops

Classic cake pops

Sweet Melissa Classics

Our dessert style pops, just like the ones we sell in the store. These come as-is.

PriceFrom $35 per dozen
Lead time1 week for pre-orders
Minimum1 dozen
Per dozen1 flavor

Not every in-store flavor is available for pre-order.

Classic flavors

Sweet Melissa Classic Cake Pops

Available to pre-order by the dozen.
For custom colors or flavor combos, choose Custom Color Pops.

Almond Joy

Coconut almond cake, milk chocolate, coconut
Biscoff Cookie Butter

Vanilla cake with cookie butter, white chocolate, Biscoff crumble
Brownie Batter

Chocolate cake, milk chocolate, brownie crumble
Cake Batter

Cake batter cake, white chocolate and sprinkles
Candy Shoppe

Chocolate cake, milk chocolate, assorted candies
Chocolate Chip

Vanilla cake with chocolate chips, white chocolate
Chocolate Covered Strawberry

Strawberry cake, milk chocolate, white chocolate drizzle
Chocolate Dipped Vanilla Party Cake

Vanilla party cake, milk chocolate, rainbow sprinkles
Chocolate Raspberry

Raspberry cake, milk chocolate, pink drizzle
Cinnamon Roll

Cinnamon cream cheese cake, cinnamon white chocolate
Coconut Cream Pie

Coconut cake, white chocolate, shredded coconut, graham crackers
Cookie Dough

Cookie dough cake, white chocolate, chocolate chips
Cookies ‘n Cream

Cookies and cream cake, white chocolate, Oreo crumble
Cotton Candy (seasonal)

Cotton candy cake, colored white chocolate
Death by Chocolate

Chocolate cake, milk chocolate, chocolate chips
Double Chocolate Oreo

Cookies and cream cake, milk chocolate, Oreo crumble
Key Lime Pie

Lime cake, white chocolate, graham crumble, white chocolate drizzle
Lemon Butter

Lemon butter cake, white chocolate
Lemon Raspberry

Lemon-raspberry cake, white chocolate
Mint Chocolate Chip

Mint vanilla cake with chocolate chips, milk chocolate, green drizzle
Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

Cinnamon cake with oats and raisins, white chocolate
PB & J

Peanut butter and raspberry jelly cake, peanut butter dip
Peanut Butter Cup

Peanut butter cake, milk chocolate, peanut butter drizzle
Peppermint Mocha

Peppermint mocha chocolate cake, dark chocolate, mint topping
Pumpkin Roll (Sept–Dec)

Pumpkin cake, white chocolate
Red Velvet

Red velvet cake, white chocolate, red velvet crumble
Red Velvet Cheesecake

Red velvet cake, white chocolate, graham crumble, red velvet crumble
Red Velvet Chocolate Chip

Red velvet cake with chocolate chips, white chocolate
Salted Caramel

Vanilla cake with salted caramel, white chocolate
S’mores

Chocolate cake with graham and marshmallows, white chocolate, milk chocolate drizzle
Snickerdoodle

Cinnamon swirl cake, white chocolate, cinnamon sugar
Snickers

Peanut butter cake, milk chocolate, white chocolate drizzle, peanuts
Strawberries and Cream

Strawberry cake, white chocolate, white sprinkles
Strawberry Crunch (seasonal)

Strawberry cake, white chocolate, strawberry crunch
Thin Mint

Chocolate mint cake, dark chocolate, chocolate crisp pearls
Vanilla Bean

Vanilla cake, white chocolate with vanilla bean flecks
Wedding Cake

Lemon-almond cake, white chocolate
White Chocolate Raspberry

Raspberry cake, white chocolate, pink drizzle
Custom orders

About Custom Cake Pops

Want pops that match your party colors, theme or wedding? Here is how custom orders work.

Pick your colors

Choose the colors, drizzles and sprinkles for your event. Custom colors are what make these pops special.

Pick your flavors

Each dozen gets one flavor, chosen from our flavor list. Designs are chosen per dozen too, one design per dozen.

Plan ahead

Custom pops need 1 week lead time. The minimum order is 1 dozen, and pricing starts at $42 per dozen and varies with your request.

Ready to order?

Send Us Your Cake Pop Request