A small family bakery, since 2014
From custom cookies baked at home to one of Middletown’s favorite places to gather. For 12 years, we’ve been bringing our community together over cakes, cookies and coffee. Thank you for making us a part of your special events and everyday moments!


Melissa started her baking business out of her home, offering custom cookies while working full time in the food service industry. In 2008 she created her own website, sweetmelissacookies.com. Late nights and very early mornings made it all happen. Her husband helped bag and box orders, and family and friends helped bake when needed.
After her first child, Melissa decided to bake full time so she could be home with her son. She expanded the menu to cupcakes, cake pops (a new and trendy item back then) and, of course, custom cakes.
She has loved to bake since she was a little girl, imagining delicious flavor combinations and creating visually striking sweets. Her passion is cakes that taste as good as they look, and every cake is an important one to her.
Fun fact: although custom sugar cookies started this business, we no longer offer them for custom orders. You’ll still find decorated sugar cookies in our case for holidays and seasons!
From a “Cakery” to a Bakery

Sweet Melissa Cake Boutique
After a year of planning, saving and prepping, Melissa’s dream of a storefront came true off of Broad Street. The small “Cakery” focused on custom orders, with a few treats like biscotti, cupcakes, cake pops and sugar cookies. The town quickly showed it wanted a full bakery, and the menu grew from there.

Sweet Melissa Bakery & Coffee Shop
After five busy years, we outgrew our first location, and in the winter of 2019 we moved to our current home on Peterson Road. Melissa and her husband Vince, who is from Italy, created a beautiful space for Middletown to relax, stocked with pastries, cakes and a full coffee bar. Vince’s hometown is a place they visit often and are inspired by.

Still family, still made in store
Melissa works hard every day to bring customers new treats while keeping the favorites. She and her crew decorate the shop for every holiday, so families, and especially the little ones, have a beautiful and memorable place to visit.
Hours & Contact
Hours
Open 7 days a week, regular hours, unless posted otherwise on our social media.
Holiday Hours
Closed Thanksgiving & Black Friday. We are always closed on Black Friday so we can decorate for Christmas!
Open Thanksgiving Eve until 6pm, like regular.
Closed December 25th through December 28th. We close for Christmas and a few days after to give our staff a little break.
Questions?
We don’t have a phone, so our team can stay focused on the customers in front of them. Email us with general storefront questions or concerns.
Custom order questions go through our order forms, so all your details stay in one place.
Stop in for a sweet treat, a coffee date with a friend or loved one, or stock up on cupcakes and cake pops for a special occasion.

