Open 7 days · Mon–Sat 8–6 · Sun 9–6 · 5407 Peterson Rd, Middletown, DE · Get directions
Custom orders

Custom Cakes

Birthday, shower, baptism, communion and celebration cakes, made to taste as good as they look. Every cake is an important one to us!

Unicorn custom cake
Pricing guide

Cake sizing & pricing

Cake sizing

Our cakes run large: about 6 inches tall per tier, with 4–5 layers of cake. One serving is about 2 pieces of a standard sheet cake.

6″ cakefeeds 10–12
8″ cakefeeds 15–20
9″ cakefeeds 20–30
10″ cakefeeds 25–35
12″ cakefeeds 30–40
Smallest 2 tier30–40 servings
Smallest 3 tier50–60 servings

Starting prices

Buttercream, single tier$5.50 / serving
Buttercream, two tier$7.50 / serving
Upgraded filling+$1 / serving
Buttercream with fondant accents$10 / serving
Fondant covered & detailed$12 / serving

These are estimates. For exact pricing, send an order request with your inspiration photos.

Our customers love

Example cakes & pricing

Single tier cake with fondant accents and bear topper

Single tier with fondant accents

$10 per serving, 10 serving minimum. About $150 to start for 15 servings; as shown, $195 with the bear topper and wood-look board.

Two tier unicorn custom cake

Two tier with fondant accents

$10 per serving, 30 serving minimum. About $300 for 30 servings.

Three tier fondant covered cake

Three tier fondant covered

Fondant covered cakes start at $12 per serving. This design is $15 per serving, starting at 50 servings, so $750.

Gallery

Cakes we specialize in

Hundreds more photos of our work are on our Facebook page.

Baby Showers & Baptisms

See more on Facebook

Little Girl Cakes

See more on Facebook

Little Boy Cakes

See more on Facebook

Teen & Tween Cakes

See more on Facebook

Celebration Cakes

See more on Facebook

Important info

Custom cake ordering

1

Check the calendar

Review the availability calendar, then fill out the cake form. Please don’t stop in to discuss a cake order.

2

Tell us the details

Include your date, how many you’re feeding, your budget and photos of your ideas. Flavors aren’t needed until 1 week before.

3

Watch your inbox

You’ll get an automatic reply right away, and we respond within 3 days. Check your spam folder. An inquiry is not an order yet.

4

Pay your deposit

Melissa personally walks you through pricing and emails your invoice. No cake is booked without a deposit paid by the due date.

Lead times

1 week is the bare minimum for any cake, with deposit. We suggest 1–2 months for most custom cakes, since many dates book out. Basic round cakes can sometimes fit in on "booked" dates.

What we don’t make

We don’t make sheet cakes or sugar cookies, and we won’t exactly copy another cake artist’s work. Every cake is custom made to suit you, and we can combine all your favorite ideas.

Need a cake today?

We carry grab-and-go cakes in the store daily. They can’t be customized except for writing on top.

Ready?

Check your date & send your cake request

Sweet Melissa Bakery & Coffee Shop · Family owned & operated since 2014 · 5407 Peterson Rd, Middletown, DE 19709 (directions) · melissa@sweetmelissade.com · We do not have a phone